Dressage

With 50 entries in the Dressage yesterday I knew it would be a long day. I had booked two Dressage Judges only to find out on sat evening at 7pm that one wasn’t coming. So I am very grateful to Lynn Groves who stood in at the last minute. Steve took Amelia to The Hand Equestrian Centre in Somerset to jump Destiny and Leo. Which left only me to run the Dressage. Olwen Wilkins judged the first two classes and as I did not have someone to write for Olwen Sarah did it. Sarah was supposed to be opening the shop so I did managed to run back and fore and run the shop, the scoring and any other problems. Class 2 was started a little better Helen wrote so Sarah was able to do the shop. Tracey was clipping Fred for Zoe in his stable when I got a message to say that Fred had reared up and struck Tracey in the side with his front leg and she had hit her head against the wall so I left the Dressage and helped Tracey to finish Fred, Tracey was ok, bit shook up and probably very stiff today. Getting back to the dressage at the end of the class Carys added the scores up for me. Lynn Groves took over Judging for the next three classes which included the Pony Club Dengie Dressage. There was a concern over the Dengie as to whether it was allowed to be called which I have spoken to Pony Club about and it is allowed to be called at Prelim level. Very well done to Mollyann Rees who won the Dengie. It was a shame for Kate Owen who was representing Talygarn as the first four qualified and Kate was 5th but we were pleased she did so well.  There were no particular problems in the day although some people aired some strong opinions regarding their unhappiness at some of the results. I would like to say that over the years when watching or competing I have sometimes wondered why certain people have won or been placed in classes but I am not a dressage judge and therefore accept the decision. When ever I have written for Judges that have judged for me I have to say that all judges although may have opinions that differ from each other always do their best to mark what is in front of them and to be fair. A friend of mine who is also a judge told me that British Dressage discourages judges from giving low marks these days in order to be encouraging at this level. I think and this is my opinion that if people are only marked between 5 and 7 with the odd 8’s then it does become difficult to seperate people and its anyones guess who will win. Many years ago when I did some Dressage if you did a movment particularly badly you risked a 1 or a 2 and I think thats the way it should be . Marking between 0 and 10 as it says on the Dressage sheet would make things much fairer. Very few people at the level of unaffiliated Dressage would receive a 10 and I have yet to see a score sheet with 10 on it but I have seen a lot of very bad (1) and bad (2) movements and those marks don’t come up either. If someone rides a sufficient movement and gets a 5 and someone else rides a poor movement but only gets a 4 then winning becomes a lottery. Instead of moaning about the Judges maybe people should complain to British Dressage about their scoring system and of course its never the people that win that complain. I would also like to say I saw some lovely riding yesterday and everybody was very well turned out.  Amelia had a pretty good day she had a 5th on leo in the 1.15m and won the metre class on Destiny.

Posted on Tuesday, February 9th, 2010 at 1:55 am You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.